Third graders outraged by tree cutting
Diane Abraham, on behalf of 22 third graders
4/23/2008 11:00:46 PM
  View Comments Post Comment

My students have an active interest in preservation of our special island home, and are obviously outraged at the tree killings (the identify and names of students kept confidential under the Federal Student Privacy Protection Act).

“I think that Molokai Ranch shouldn’t be cutting down our ‘aina. I think that they should be taking care of the trees at Kaluakoi Golf Course because that’s our ‘aina and we need to take care of them, and not cut them down. It took 30 years for them to look beautiful.”

“I don’t know who is/are cutting down our healthy trees, but whoever it is, they should be ashamed because that’s really, really said and those healthy trees are part of our whole community. It also makes us really, really strong to do nice things like helping people who need help. So whoever is doing this awful thing should be ashamed.”

“Please don’t cut down these trees. These trees are important to the people of Molokai. And these trees are very, very beautiful. And the trees are very precious to this island.”

“If they cut down all the trees, then there will be no more, and then the people that live when we die will not get to see the trees. The coconut palms are precious to the Hawaiian Islands and are part of our ‘aina. These people should stop killing these trees!”

“Please do not cut down those trees. Those trees are very important to people in Hawaii. You can call my dad to build you a fence [instead of the coconut tree barricades]. These coconut palm trees are very beautiful. My dad is a contractor. He can build you a fence instead. His business is Hoopaa Construction.com. You might see his truck driving around, it’s white and has a sign on the sides. So, please, don’t cut down those trees. You can get other things like plywood or metal fencing. Put up that fencing around the golf course and then put up signs.

“Please don’t cut down these trees. These trees are important to the people of Molokai. And these trees are very, very beautiful. And the trees are very precious to this island.”

An especially outraged student who actually though how a tree would feel says:

“You should have an imaginary electrical line around, so when Molokai Ranch pushes over [a tree], they will get a shock or get burnt to death, for cutting down the trees, because that’s how the coconut trees feel now.”

I think the keiki have the right idea.

Diane Abraham, on behalf of 22 third graders
Kualapuu School

Comments


While there is little to justify the cutting of the trees, the comment previously mentioned should have been left out.

4/27/2008, 10:19:58 AM

"... they will get a shock or get burnt to death, for cutting down the trees..

I think the keiki have the right idea.

Diane Abraham"

One human life is more precioius than any amount of coconut trees.

For the sake of fairness, a teacher should be unbiased and discuss both sides of a story.



4/26/2008, 8:13:06 PM
"Shocked or Burnt to Death" is this the way normal 3rd graders think????
If this is the way the future of Molokai thinks standby for lots of violence!!

4/26/2008, 5:30:51 PM
Third graders aren't hard to convince. Many still believe in Santa and the Tooth Fairy. Guess that goes for you too.

This is an absurd argument about a landowner maintaining his landscaping, as is his right and also his legal obligation. These aren't naturally occuring trees...someone planted them in the first place as artificial landscaping in an area where they do not normally occur. Coco palms certainly are not endangered here or anyplace else any more than roaches are.

Get a life and quit picking scabs off the carcass of the Ranch.

4/26/2008, 9:22:23 AM
I doubt that it took much convincing on behalf of a teacher to demonstrate what a terrible and malicious act it was in cutting down thirty healthy coconut trees. Even a third grader could easily understand this.

4/25/2008, 7:17:45 PM
It is an outrage to see a teacher laying her political eco-trip on her students rather than teaching them to see both sides of the question. Everything is black and white here...no grey scale.

There would have been a public outcry if the Ranch had enclosed the golf course with chain link fencing and it would have been costly and consumed lots of steel which required lots of fossil fuel to produce. At least, using the fallen palms as a block to vehicles, everyone still has foot access to the course and the scenic coastline and scenic views aren't marred with an artificial barrier.

4/25/2008, 3:51:01 PM
.




Sierra Club
make payment | contact us

molokaitimes.com is copyrighted and is the
design and code of Molokai resident Tim Kline